Result of Thursday's debate - motion passes after spirited fightback from opposition team
Last Thursday witnessed a great victory for two of CLDS' newest speakers whose hard work, energy, and research helped them see off two of the club's most experienced members in a hotly contested debate. Well done!
Below you can find a full summary of the debate, but first take a look at our new e-zine, designed to provide a broader and more personalised view of all debating events across London - it's also the best way to keep up with what we have planned for 2013, which is a lot!
Debate Summary:
This House believes that the justice system should prioritise rehabilitation over punishment.
Preliminary vote: For 16, Against 4, Abstaining 3
Key arguments
- Proposition: The justice system should not eliminate punishment, but it should be rebalanced so that rehabilitation is valued more highly than punishment.
- Opposition: The justice system should be set up so that it balances punishment and rehabilitation so that neither is prioritised over the other.
- Proposition: Rehabilitation saves money in the long run as it lowers prison numbers and turns criminals into productive members of society.
- Opposition: There is a large cost to the proposition's plans which would need to be paid upfront.
- Proposition: The treatment of criminals should be worked out on a case by case basis in order to maximise the chances of them rehabilitating.
- Opposition: The treatment of criminals should be worked out so that the punishment they?receive?matches the crime they have committed.
- Opposition: Society not only needs justice to be done but also needs to see that justice is done.
- Proposition: Concentrating on punishing the criminal and allowing society to view that encourages society as a whole to be more vengeful.
- Proposition: Punishment is not as effective as rehabilitation in lowering crime levels overall.
- Opposition: Rehabilitation is really difficult to get right and setting it to be a higher priority than punishment will cause failures in the justice system.
Trending questions:
- People have to choose to be rehabilitated. ?How is the proposition going to deal with those who don't choose to be rehabilitated?
- Aren't measures that the proposition has described as rehabilitation (such as drug treatment programs and work in prison) actually forms of punishment?
Final vote: For 13, Against 10, Abstentions 3
Final vote (no abstentions): For 16, Against 10
MOTION PASSED
Joining CLDS:
Membership of the Debating society is free of charge as is admission to each of our debates. If you would like to join, simply email us at?central.debating@gmail.com?
Once you're on our mailing list, you'll receive notifications of all upcoming events and will be eligible to speak at a debate or even try your hand at chairing.
Follow us on Facebook and Twitter:
Join our facebook group and sign up for all our latest events and news updates.Follow @centraldebating
Debate Training (NEW):
CLDS now also offers professional debate training for people eager to improve their speaking and critical thinking skills. Our next workshop is on Wednesday 23 January.?See our?website?and get in touch if you would like to know more.Best Wishes
The CLDS Team
Source: http://debating-london.blogspot.com/2013/01/results-of-last-debate-and-latest-clds.html
laron landry mary j blige burger king islands joe flacco 2013 nissan altima masters par 3 contest google augmented reality glasses
কোন মন্তব্য নেই:
একটি মন্তব্য পোস্ট করুন